• markets
  • security
  • news
  • 17 min

MEV Bots Got a Taste of Their Own Sandwich

After a $25M exploit targeting Ethereum trading bots, a court had to decide where arbitrage ends and crypto fraud begins.

0

nft.eu
  • rating +20
  • subscribers 90

After a $25M exploit targeting Ethereum trading bots, a court had to decide where arbitrage ends and crypto fraud begins.

Trading bots that made money off other people's Ethereum trades lost millions in seconds when two MIT graduates exploited a vulnerability in the network's infrastructure. US prosecutors tried to prove the brothers had committed fraud, but the court cleared them of all charges. The case showed that the rules trading bots rely on to make money aren't necessarily backed by law.

What Happened

In April 2023, brothers Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, both MIT graduates and sons of an MIT professor, decided to profit from bots that regularly made money at other traders' expense: sandwich attack bots.

Bueno brothers. Source: X
Bueno brothers. Source: X

These bots watch for other users' crypto buy orders and place their own trades just before and after the orders go through. First, a bot buys a token, pushing up its price. The user's swap then goes through at a worse rate, and the bot sells what it bought to pocket the difference.

The brothers decided to turn the bots' own strategy against them. They placed orders designed to lure the bots in, then exploited a vulnerability in MEV-Boost, the system Ethereum validators use to receive prebuilt transaction blocks. That let them see the bots' hidden trades and change the block's contents so the bots lost money instead of making the profits they expected.

In just 12 seconds, the bots' owners lost around $25M, which went to the brothers.

Why the Court Cleared the Peraire-Bueno Brothers

The brothers were arrested in May 2024 on fraud and money laundering charges. Their first trial ended without a verdict: in November 2025, the jury failed to reach a unanimous decision. On November 16, 2026, a federal court in New York cleared the Peraire-Bueno brothers of all charges.

The judge found no evidence of deception. According to court records, the brothers had exploited a vulnerability and disrupted the normal processing of transactions, but they had never promised anyone that the bots would make the profits they expected. The fake data they fed into the system didn't sway the court, either. The software never checked those inputs, so they had no effect on what it did.

Prosecutors tried to present Ethereum's technical instructions as binding rules. But the court rejected that argument: a blockchain has no single set of terms of service, and going against other participants' expectations isn't, by itself, proof of criminal intent.

Editor-in-Chief's Take

These guys made $25M in 12 seconds? We're clearly in the wrong line of work.

Quite the story: the predators became the prey. The brothers didn't target ordinary Ethereum users. They went after MEV bots that made money through sandwich attacks. I've lost money on spreads like that myself, and I quietly hated those bots until decentralized exchanges started pushing back against them.

For years, these algorithms made money off other people's trades and called it arbitrage. But when someone outplayed those same bots, suddenly there was talk of a crime.

The ruling showed just how legally murky the “code is law” philosophy can be: if the code doesn't prohibit something, it's allowed. Market participants may be used to software behaving a certain way, but that doesn't make their expectations legally binding on everyone else.

And I think this is less a victory for hackers than the beginning of the end for the gray area MEV bots operate in. Developers will now have to figure out when profiting from transactions is legitimate and when it crosses the line into abusing the infrastructure.

I'm glad the brothers were cleared. Basically, they took advantage of something that wasn't prohibited and outplayed the algorithms that had been making money at other traders' expense.

Source: X
Source: X

This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute advertising or investment advice. Please do your own research before making any decisions.

0

Comments

0